Ignoring the Constitution in SVG
By Nathan ‘Jolly’ Green. November 09. 2020
It first happened in 2010 with Girlyn Miguel. Then when Sir Louis Straker was made Deputy Prime Minister in 2015, Peter Binose wrote in 2015 and pointed out that there was legally no such position and therefore no such office.
There was no Constitutional provision whatsoever for such a position to be occupied or even to be established, there was total silence they ignored Binose, made no reply. There were many instances then, and since, of ignoring the Constitution and doing whatever they liked, even if unconstitutional.
Many of the things Binose brought to our attention remain to this day unanswered.
The Governor-General is appointed by the Monarch on the advice of the people of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines or the Prime Minister and takes an oath of allegiance to Queen Elizabeth II, who is Queen of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines and Head of State. Executive authority is vested in the Monarch, though much of it can be exercisable only by the Governor-General on behalf of the Sovereign of the independent Saint Vincent and the Grenadines.
Ralph Gonsalves is not World Boss; I am sure most in the hemisphere had a good laugh at his expense, to the humiliation of all Vincentians.
Creating the Office of Deputy Prime Minister
Under the terms of the 1979 Constitution of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, it is not Constitutional and therefore not legal to select, appoint, any person and swear them in as a Deputy Prime Minister. There is no such provision in the Constitution; the ULP Government has no right to present a person to be Deputy Prime Minister as they have done by asking the Governor-General swear in North Windward member of Parliament Montgomery Daniel.
The Constitution only allows for three Deputy positions, Deputy to Governor-General, Deputy Speaker, and Deputy Commissioner of Police.
If there were any intention by the draftsmen of the 1979 Constitution to include such a position and title in the Constitution, they would have made provision within the Constitution Deed for the position of Deputy Prime Minister. There is no provision for such a role. If a Deputy Prime Minister were required the political masters at the time would have insisted that the position of Deputy Prime Minister be included in the Constitution, they did not. In fact, by excluding it compounds the reasoning that they deliberately did not want to have such a position or office.
Despite that, there are provisions within the Constitution for a stand-in for the Prime Minister due to illness or absence.
Performance of Functions of Prime Minister During Absence or Illness
54. (1) Whenever the Prime Minister is absent from Saint Vincent or by reason of illness is unable to perform the functions conferred upon him by this Constitution, the Governor-General may authorize some other minister to perform those functions (other than the functions conferred by this section), and that minister may perform those functions until the Governor General revokes his authority.
(2) The powers of the Governor-General under this section will be exercised by him with the accordance of the advice of the Prime Minister;
Provided that if the Governor-General, acting in his own deliberate judgment, considers that it is impracticable to obtain the advice of the Prime Minister owing to his absence or illness he may exercise those powers without that advice and in his own deliberate judgment.
Saint Vincent and the Grenadines Constitution is online and available for everyone to read: –
http://www.oas.org/juridico/PDFs/mesicic4_svg_const.pdf
There is no provision in the Constitution for the Governor-General to appoint or make someone a Deputy Prime Minister, not permanently or for any other term or period whatsoever, not even temporarily.
There is no provision for a Deputy Prime Minister, an Acting Prime Minister, or Temporary Prime Minister to be appointed to act at the same time as the Prime Minister as an aid, as an assistant to the Prime Minister, or at all. For instance for such a so-called Deputy Prime Minister to go abroad or to the UN to carry out duties or to attend as Deputy Prime Minister may be Ultra Vires, as may be the very naming and making of such an office or title. And therefore, any treaties, Bills, Laws, contracts, or legal documents he will sign may be refutable, unenforceable, and without force or legal reason.
The Prime Minister and the Government are subject to the law, the law is subject to the Constitution, whether acting by prerogative power or otherwise. The rule of law protects the sovereignty of Parliament, not the assertion of power by the Executive over the Legislature.
Is it “ultra vires” et separatim “unconstitutional” for the Prime Minister, to purport to advise the Governor-General to swear in a minister under the title of Deputy Prime Minister when there is no provision to do so in the Constitution.
Now in 2020, once again Prime Minister Dr Ralph E Gonsalves advised the Governor-General to swear in someone as Deputy Prime Minister. And that happened when the elected representative for North Windward Montgomery Daniel was sworn in as Deputy Prime Minister at Government House on Saturday 7th November 2020.
I am calling for an investigation into the authority to make this man Deputy Prime Minister and if it is a gross violation of the 1979 Constitution of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines.
NDP what is your opinion?
[The singular includes the plural and vice versa and he shall include she; Following the custom in regulations, references to “he” or “him” include “she” or “her”, and so on. In this policy and associated guidance, “he” is deemed to include “she”]
If anyone thinks what I have written here is in any way incorrect, please make comments below, or write a reply to this and ask the editor to post it.
END
IMAGES: Supplied by author
DISCLAMER: The opinion, belief and viewpoint expressed by the author do not necessarily reflect the opinion, belief and viewpoint of iNews Cayman/ieyenews.com or official policies of iNews Cayman/ieyenews.com
As expressed earlier Nathan ‘Jolly’ Green, a people who do not have “any concepts of freedom” or “any consequential desire to be free,” will unhappily remain in utter bondage. This sadly do appear to be the ongoing case on the mainland of St Vincent and the Grenadines.
The many years of past “conditioning” and poor educational attainment, have resulted in a largely uneducated, impoverished, poverty stricken dunce mass, an impoverished mass who are indeed very docile and totally unconcerned as to the reality of freedom or any concepts of self-determination. This mass have again very easily fell victims to the usual election bribes of cash, hand out of material goods and verbal falsehoods.
Moreover, in this past election round, the opposition leadership was as much to blame for their drubbing loss as the docile mass of mainland Vincentians. Why you may ask?
It is for this very reason. It was quite obvious that the opposition leadership was largely missing throughout the past five years. Dr Friday was largely missing without actions, leaving his party to struggle even in presenting just a simple narrative, even to that simple docile mass.
Not once did Dr Friday offer the dunce mass, that if elected to power, that he would seek to enact the now infamous and missing “Freedom of Information Bill”, nor did he offer, if elected, to curb the excesses of future Governments.
Common abuses that are now common with the Gonsalves in their constant abuses of power, by Dr Friday introducing “new parliamentary curbs”. Nor was Dr Friday to put an end to the constant bypassing of enacted parliamentary rules in government decision making.
The result was that the oppressive dictatorship of the slippery and tricky Gonsalves family, was left to control the ongoing narrative of “prosperity later” while using the antics of Love boxes, other material handouts, cash giveaways and the delusional folly of world leadership.
Perhaps it’s time to emigrate!
Indeed it is hard to understand why the Leader of the opposition in SVG Dr Friday, was so inactive and quiet during the past five years leading up to the SVG General Election, he knowing full well just how slippery and tricky his political scientist opponent Ralph Gonsalves, the avowed socialist is. Such inactivity and obvious quietness on the side of Dr Friday left the door wide open for Ralph Gonsalves to make much mischief, which he did.
Moreover, it is even harder to understand why Dr Friday did not put clear blue water between his predecessor’s Arnhim Eustace’s poison-challis policies and his own, particular that of a “one China policy” a policy that was handed to Dr Friday by the parting Arnhim Eustace.
That singular neglectful failure by Dr Friday, had allowed the cunning socialist, Ralph Gonsalves, follower of both the Communist regimes in Cuba and Venezuela, to warn Vincentians of a pending COMMUNIST takeover in SVG and the possibilities of debt traps by the Communist in China, should the silent Dr Friday win the election.
The irony was obviously lost on the dunce SVG voters, as they pocketed their cash handouts, received their “love boxes” and bagged their material gains, even as the Gonsalves had in a pre-election action, just taken away some lands from an extended family and earmarked Gonsalves said for redistribution in obvious communist fashion.
https://www.iwnsvg.com/2020/08/17/video-communist-land-acquisition-in-svg/
Would the same political ineptitude on the side of Dr Friday continue to keep his NDP out of government in SVG? Will Dr Friday continue to be the quiet man of Vincentian politics? Only time will tell! Whatever happens, save for an act of God, the Gonsalves are not going anywhere soon.
Me hear dem say some ah SVG ah na happy wid de outcome ah de recent election at all, which nah go surprise me!
Dem ah ask fo de Gonsalves dem fo go do de moral ting an call fo another election, as de man Ralph Gonsalves did do in 1998, wen de boot was arn de odder foot. Ah wah? Morality an Ralph Gonsalves? https://www.iwnsvg.com/2020/11/15/morally-wrong-in-1998-and-2020/ dat ah joke!
But wait sarr, dem people day ah forget dat de man Ralph is not a moral man fram time! A nah im did say so im self? Ah nah im did tell we dat im sometimes tell lies? An wah? Dem say “power corrupts” so wah an nah true?
De man Kenrick Quashie ah write, “The political parties should lead their respective battles for the seat of government and; the church, the almost dying civil society, trade unions, intellectuals and progressives should lead the charge to educate our people on the constitutional amendment.” Wah?
Kenrick Quashie dread, even de churches dem ah SVG need some training into what are moral behaviours! https://www.iwnsvg.com/2020/11/03/was-sundays-gospel-event-really-about-god/
Well now, me see dat de man Jomo Sanga Thomas ah ask we a moral question for consideration. Im ah ask, “For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, but lose his soul?” Im well right! So with such in mind perhaps we can listen to Dr Masters who ha something fo say arn dat matter https://www.metropolitantabernacle.org/Sermons-Online/Sermons-by-Peter-Masters